Caster Semenya: Double Olympic Champion 'Not Ashamed of Being Different'

Two-time Olympic champion Caster Semenya refuses to be ashamed of her uniqueness and remains steadfast in her fight against discrimination from athletics authorities. Born with differences of sexual development (DSD), the 32-year-old South African is barred from competing in female track events unless she undergoes testosterone-reducing treatment. Semenya is challenging World Athletics, asserting that their regulations discriminate against athletes with hyperandrogenism.

In a recent interview with BBC Breakfast's Sally Nugent, Semenya emphasized her commitment to fighting battles against authorities rather than pursuing medals. Despite her remarkable achievements, including Olympic gold in 2012 and 2016 and three-time world champion titles, Semenya has shifted her focus away from competing at the Paris 2024 Olympics.

Hyperandrogenism, a medical condition characterized by elevated testosterone levels, is at the center of Semenya's struggle. Introduced in 2018, regulations stipulate that athletes with DSD can only participate in female track events between 400m and the mile if they reduce their testosterone levels. March saw a further ruling by World Athletics, requiring DSD athletes to undergo hormone-suppressing treatment for six months before competing in all female events.

Semenya, undeterred by the challenges, expressed her belief that being a woman transcends physical differences. She staunchly affirms her identity and rejects societal expectations, stating, "For me, I believe if you are a woman, you are a woman, no matter the differences you have." Despite facing adversity and medical scrutiny, she remains resolute in embracing her uniqueness. Refusing to succumb to societal norms, Semenya declares, "I am not going to be ashamed because I am different. I am different and special, and I feel great about it."

Semenya's journey extends beyond the track, as she champions the importance of women's sports and advocates for women to take control of their bodies. Her resilience extends to the European Court of Human Rights, which ruled in her favor regarding testosterone levels in female athletes. In the face of controversy and challenges, Caster Semenya stands as a beacon of self-affirmation, pushing for the acknowledgment and acceptance of diverse identities in the world of sports.

"If we are woman enough or not, it is up to us. We know and believe in what is right, then why must we stop."

Caster Semenya's legal battle extends beyond the confines of sports regulations. The case at the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) isn't against sporting bodies or specific DSD rules but is a targeted challenge against the government of Switzerland. This legal saga traces its origins back to a Swiss Supreme Court ruling three years ago, demonstrating the enduring nature of Semenya's quest for justice.

The ECHR's recent findings reveal that the Swiss government failed to protect Semenya from discrimination when its Supreme Court upheld the decision by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), affirming World Athletics' rules. The case is now on its way to the Grand Chamber of the ECHR for a final ruling, prompted by a referral request from the Swiss government.

Semenya contends that adhering to testosterone-reducing medication could jeopardize her health, emphasizing that the ruling denies her and fellow athletes with DSD the right to rely on their natural abilities. In her candid revelations, she recalls discovering her uniqueness at the age of five and, in her autobiography, disclosed the results of a gender test in 2009 that unveiled she "did not have a uterus or fallopian tubes."

Unwavering in her authenticity, Semenya asserts, "I am a woman and have a vagina just like any other woman. I am living a different life, and I will continue living that, as that is what makes me feel good. I am not going to be somebody I am not, as I have to fit in to be accepted."

Beyond her athletic achievements, Semenya envisions a broader purpose. Having achieved her goals on the track, she now aspires to pave the way for the fair treatment of every young girl. Her focus has shifted towards fighting injustice, promoting inclusivity and diversity. Rejecting the intrusion of selfish motives, she emphasizes empowering women and ensuring they have a voice. Semenya issues a call to action for women to stand up for themselves, asserting, "Let's wake up as women and fight for what is right." Her unwavering commitment to justice and advocacy reflects a determination to reshape the narrative of women's experiences in the realm of sports and beyond.

She added: "[Sporting leaders] are turning women against women. If you say you're acting in the best interests of athletes, then do that. It's not up to you to decide what gender should look like, what sex should look like. Govern, make money, promote sport. Very clear message and very loud — do the job, promote the sport and let us sports people entertain."

Caster Semenya, in her bold stance against sporting authorities, criticizes the divisive impact of their decisions on women in sports. She argues that these leaders are fostering discord among women athletes, urging them to prioritize the genuine welfare of athletes rather than attempting to dictate standards of gender and appearance. Emphasizing a straightforward message, she calls on sporting bodies to focus on their core responsibilities: governance, financial management, and the promotion of sports. In her view, the primary role of these leaders should be to facilitate sports entertainment, allowing athletes to showcase their talents without unnecessary interference.

Last week, World Athletics responded to these criticisms, asserting in a statement to Reuters: "World Athletics has only ever been interested in protecting the female category. If we don't, then women and young girls will not choose sport. That is, and has always been, the federation's sole motivation." A spokesperson further explained to the BBC, stating, "World Athletics has 15 years of data, observations, and information directly from DSD athletes in our own sport that show high testosterone levels do provide an unfair advantage in the female category — and that our guidelines on testosterone thresholds are necessary, reasonable, and proportionate in our aim to protect the integrity of the female category." The response underscores World Athletics' commitment to what they perceive as safeguarding the fairness and integrity of women's sports, relying on data and guidelines to support their stance on testosterone thresholds.

In conclusion, Caster Semenya's unwavering stand against sporting authorities reflects a broader narrative centered on the rights and identities of women athletes. By challenging regulations that she perceives as discriminatory, Semenya asserts her right to compete based on her natural abilities, emphasizing the need to redefine societal norms regarding gender and appearance. Her call for sporting leaders to focus on their core responsibilities and refrain from dictating arbitrary standards resonates with a plea for inclusivity and the protection of athletes' genuine interests.

On the other side, World Athletics maintains a stance rooted in the protection of the female category, arguing that guidelines on testosterone thresholds are crucial for maintaining a level playing field. The conflict underscores the complex interplay between safeguarding fairness in sports and respecting individual identities and abilities.

As the case proceeds to the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights, it symbolizes a pivotal moment in the ongoing dialogue about inclusivity, diversity, and the role of governing bodies in sports. Regardless of the outcome, Caster Semenya's journey has sparked crucial conversations about the intersection of gender, identity, and athleticism, challenging the status quo and pushing for a more inclusive and equitable future in the world of sports. The resolution of this case will undoubtedly have far-reaching implications for the future of women's athletics and the broader conversation surrounding individual rights and the evolving landscape of sports regulations.